Party like it's 1999
Just before 8:30 p.m. on the West Coast Monday night, the Boston Red Sox became the first franchise to twice come back from losing the first two games in the division series to win the next three and advance to the League Championship Series. At the same time, the Oakland Athletics became the first franchise to twice fall apart after winning the first two games in the division series and lose the next three to head into the offseason.
I don't know what it was like to be an A's fan in 2001, but I do know what it was like to be a Red Sox fan in 1999. How did this series compare to that series? I'm glad you asked.
Both series began just the way you would like them to -- with each team's ace toeing the rubber. Pedro Martinez against Indians ace Bartolo Colon in 1999 and Martinez against A's ace Tim Hudson this year.
The games were similar in many ways, but different in many others. In 1999, Pedro breezed through the first four innings with three hits and no runs allowed. Then, a bad back forced him out of the game before he had even pitched long enough to qualify for the win.
This year, Pedro flew through the first two innings before the A's touched him up for three runs in the third.
Back in 1999, Nomar Garciaparra had staked Pedro to a 2-0 lead before the fragile ace had to leave. Garciaparra, playing in his first game in eight days thanks to a bruised tendon in his right wrist that everybody in New England would know a lot more about all too soon, hit a solo homer in the second and doubled and scored on Mike Stanley's single in the fourth.
This year, Todd Walker gave the Red Sox an early 1-0 lead on a solo homer off Hudson in the first before Pedro let the A's jump ahead. Pedro would then settle down and pitch four more scoreless innings, by which point the Red Sox offense had regained his lead for him.
Jason Varitek's solo homer in the fifth brought Boston within a run, and Walker gave the Red Sox a 4-3 lead with his second homer of the game in the seventh inning, this time off left-handed reliever Ricardo Rincon.
So, both times the Red Sox had the lead when Pedro left the ball game. In 1999, the Red Sox turned to Derek Lowe to protect that lead, and he was brilling while allowing just one hit in four innings. Unfortunately, he also lost.
The only hit Lowe allowed was a monster home run to Jim Thome in the sixth that followed a John Valentin error that allowed Manny Ramirez to reach base safely. Ramirez would reach base without getting a hit again leading off the ninth inning when Lowe plunked him in the back. Travis Fryman later singled off Rich Garces with the bases loaded and one out to tag Lowe with the loss.
This year, the Red Sox turned to several people to protect Pedro's lead. First, Mike Timlin came in to pitch a scoreless eighth inning. The Red Sox then turned things over to embattled closer Byung-Hyun Kim, who calmly got the first out in the ninth before walking a batter and hitting another batter to put the winning run on with one out. Kim recovered to strike out Mark Ellis, but that was the end of his night.
Left-handed reliever Alan Embree came in to face left-handed hitter Erubiel Durazo with the game on the line. Durazo won the battle with a single to tie the game and force extra innings.
Just as the 1999 Red Sox were unable to get anything going on offense against Colon and Paul Shuey after the Indians tied the game, the 2003 Red Sox were unable to get anything going on offense against Chad Bradford, Keith Foulke or Rich Harden after the A's tied the game.
Scott Williamson pitched a scoreless 10th for this year's Red Sox before Lowe was called on to once again try and help the Red Sox win game one of an ALDS.
Again Lowe allowed just one hit, but it was just as big (in importance if not in distance) as the one he allowed four years ago. After a walk, two groundouts and then two more walks, Lowe was facing Ramon Hernandez with the bases loaded and two outs.
In the surprise of all surprises, Hernandez dropped down a perfect bunt and the winning run scored while the Red Sox tried to figure out what had just happened. For the second straight playoff appearance, Lowe was Boston's game one loser.
After losing the first game of each series in heartbreaking fashion after wasting a start by Pedro, the Red Sox were unable to even put up a fight in game two of either series.
In 1999, Charles Nagy toyed with the Red Sox for seven innings, allowing just one run. Meanwhile, a botched double play by Red Sox second baseman Jose Offerman opened the floodgates for a six-run third inning as the Indians routed the Red Sox 11-1.
This year, Barry Zito and his wonderful curveball toyed with the Red Sox for seven innings, allowing just one run while striking out nine. Meanwhile, an error by Red Sox second baseman Todd Walker helped the A's score five runs in the second inning of a 5-1 victory. In fairness to Walker, the Red Sox had already allowed three runs when he made his error, while the 1999 Red Sox had a 1-0 lead when Offerman erred.
So, twice I went into the postseason full of hope, and twice I watched disappointedly as the Red Sox dropped their first two games before flying home to try and bounce back in Fenway Park. The strangest part? I was unable to watch and see whether or not my beloved Red Sox would win either third game.
In 1999, I had a trip to Philadelphia the day of the third game that I couldn't miss. This year, I had a wedding to go and the reception started at 6 p.m. with the game starting at 7:30 p.m.
In 1999, I found a pay phone in Philly and called my mom in Springfield, Mass. to ask how the Red Sox were doing as three other Red Sox fans huddled around me and the phone. We learned that the Red Sox were losing 1-0, but that Cleveland starting pitcher Dave Burba had left after four innings of shutout ball with a strained forearm.
We would later learn that the Red Sox won the game 9-3 thanks to home runs from John Valentin and Brian Daubach and a quality start from Ramon Martinez.
Saturday, one of the groomsmen at the wedding told me at one point that he had heard that the Red Sox were leading 1-0 in the fourth or fifth inning. That was all I heard of the game until one of my friends, Todd, called me not long before midnight to tell me that was one of the best endings to a game he had ever seen. I told him I hadn't been able to watch it and he told me that Doug Mirabelli hit a two-run walkoff home run in the 11th inning to win the game for the Red Sox.
I would later learn that it was Trot Nixon who hit the home run, with Mirabelli scoring ahead of him, and that the A's had cost themselves an almost certain shot at sweeping the series thanks to some bad defense and some horrendous baserunning (some people think the A's should have won that game even with their baserunning and defensive mistakes, but that's simply not the case. They were not screwed out of a win by the umpires).
I would also later learn that Lowe had allowed just one run in 8.1 innings after having made the gradual and very strange transformation from setup man (1999) to elite closer (2000) to inept closer (2001) to Cy Young caliber starter (2002) to inconsistent starter (2003).
So, the Red Sox had battled off an elimination game in each series and, though they were still certainly the underdogs with a 2-1 deficit, they had life. And I, after a one-game hiatus each year, was able to watch those new lives.
In the game fours, Boston's opponents both brought their ace game one starters back on three days rest while the Red Sox saved Pedro both times out of necessity. In 1999 he still had the bad back and this year he had thrown 130 pitches in game one.
So it was up to Kent Mercker to beat Colon and John Burkett to beat Hudson. Except that's not really what happened either year.
Neither Colon nor Mercker were able to escape the second inning in 1999, but the Red Sox got the better of the exchange, leading 7-2 after two. They continued to bash the Indians pitching staff into submission, winning 23-7 to even the series at two games apiece with one of the most fun games I have ever had the pleasure of watching.
This year, Hudson pitched a scoreless first inning, but had to leave before the second inning due to injury. Burkett worked his way out of a bases loaded and nobody out jam in the second with just one run scoring, and the Red Sox were able to take a 2-1 lead thanks to Johnny Damon's two-run homer off Steve Sparks.
Burkett worked his way in and out of trouble for a few more innings and the Red Sox still led 2-1 going into the top of the sixth. That's when Grady Little tried to get greedy. He let Burkett pitch to the first batter, who singled. He let Burkett pitch to the next batter, who Burkett got out on a hard liner to third base. He let Burkett pitch to the third batter, who tripled to tie the game at 2-2. Finally, he let Burkett pitch to Jermaine Dye, who homered to give Oakland a 4-2 lead.
Burkett's night over 1-4 batters too late, Tim Wakefield and Williamson combined to finish the game without any more Oakland runs scoring. The question was whether or not even that would be good enough to let the Boston offense rally.
Todd Walker cut the deficit in half immediately, hitting his third homer of the series and his second off Ricardo Rincon in the bottom of the sixth, but the Red Sox went quietly in the seventh.
Then, the A's brought in Foulke yet again to try and get a long save starting in the eighth. Damon grounded out and Nomar doubled off the wall. Walker flied out to center and Ramirez singled into left field, but too hard to score Nomar with the tying run.
That brought up David Ortiz, who had been hitless in the series thus far. Cookie Monster drove a 3-2 pitch to deep right field, where Dye might have been able to catch it and certainly should have been able to field it cleanly enough to prevent Ramirez from scoring. He did neither, and the Red Sox had a 5-4 lead that turned into a 5-4 win when Williamson slammed the door shut.
So, twice the Red Sox lost the first two games of their division series, twice they came back to Fenway Park to even the series at two games apiece, and twice they headed back out onto the road one win away from a date with the New York Yankees in the ALCS. There were two differences between 1999 and 2003 going into game five.
First, this year the Red Sox knew they had Pedro on the hill for the fifth and deciding game whereas the following quotes were being made about Pedro in 1999:
Team doctor Arthur Pappas said it was "possible but not probable" that Martinez would be available tonight.
Pitching coach Joe Kerrigan said it was "unrealistic."
"I just don't think it's wise to start him," manager Jimy Williams said. "I don't know if he can pitch at all, to be very honest."
Second, in 1999, I was able to watch the fifth game with my suitemates, two of whom were (and still are) Red Sox fans and one of whom was (and still is) an Indians fan. This year, I had to work on the night the all-important game was being played.
The 1999 game was a seesaw affair from the beginning, with the Sox taking a 2-0 lead in the top of the first and falling behind 3-2 in the bottom of the inning. The Indians extended their lead to 5-2 in the second, but the Red Sox took a 7-5 lead in the third thanks to a Troy O'Leary grand slam following an intentional walk to Nomar. However, the Indians jumped back ahead 8-7 in the bottom of the third before the Red Sox tied it at eight runs apiece in the top of the fourth.
And that's when the game ended.
Obviously it didn't really end there, but that's when Pedro came in and you just had a feeling (or at least my suitemates -- even the Indians fan -- and I did) that the Indians were done.
Pedro didn't allow the Indians to score -- or even get a hit -- for the next six innings and the Red Sox got all the offense they'd need when the Indians intentionally walked Nomar again and O'Leary homered again, this time a three-run shot.
I remember the two Red Sox fans and myself jumping on the furniture and running around the suite while the Indians fan sunk deeper and deeper into his chair. The three of us too young to remember 1986 firsthand with any sort of clarity, this was the first time we had experienced the Red Sox winning a postseason series. And that was my happiest day as a baseball fan. Until Monday.
Monday, as I said, I had to work. Luckily, I work in the sports department at the newspaper in Rochester, NY and we always have the two TVs there tuned to sporting events. So, I was able to watch the game while I worked.
At first it looked like Pedro and Zito might match zeroes all night as both looked very sharp, but Pedro cracked first, allowing a run in the fourth on a walk and a double.
Zito was not only brilliant through the first five innings, allowing just two hits and no runs, he was also efficient, throwing just 62 pitches. In the top of the sixth, however, Varitek reached him for a solo homer to tie the game at 1-1 and I gave my first fist pump and yelp of joy of the night.
Then, it looked like Zito started to tire quickly, walking Damon and hitting Walker with a Nomar foul pop up mixed in. Up came Ramirez and I know this sounds like a load of bull, but I just felt like he was going to go deep. He went very deep, tagging a 2-2 pitch well into the left field stands to give the Red Sox a 4-1 lead.
I felt comfortable at that point, but Boston didn't make it easy. Pedro gave a run back in the sixth and, after a gruesome collision between Damon and Damian Jackson in the seventh, he quickly gave another run back in the eighth. Alan Embree and Timlin finished the eighth for Pedro, so the Red Sox went to the bottom of the ninth with a 4-3 lead.
Williamson, who had been so good (and maybe overused) in the first four games, walked the first four batters he faced. So, the pitcher who had pitched in games one, three and five in 1999 came in to pitch for his third time in this series after already appearing in games one and three.
Hernandez immediately bunted the runners over to second and third with one out, so Lowe had to get the next two outs very carefully to preserve the win.
Adam Melhuse took Lowe's first pitch for a ball and then fouled off the next one. He took another ball before another foul evened the count at 2-2. Then Lowe delivered a nasty pitch that started inside and then darted back over the corner of the plate at the last moment for a called strike three.
Chris Singleton came up next and took the first two pitches for balls. He then took ball three high, but it was called a strike and he fouled off the next pitch to even the count at 2-2. With the A's one strike away from elimination, Lowe delievered two more balls to load the bases with two outs for Terrence Long.
You may remember that Lowe intentionally walked Long in game one, but he didn't want to. If I need to get an Oakland hitter out in a tough spot and I got to choose which hitter it was, I'm pretty sure I'd pick Long.
Anyway, Lowe's first pitch to Long was right down the middle for a called strike. The next pitch was a ball, and Long fouled off the next pitch to fall behind 1-2. Then, another absolutely nasty pitch from Lowe that snuck over the corner for a called third strike to put the Red Sox in the ALCS.
In 1999, I was very happy, but I could believe what was happening. The Red Sox just pounded their way past the Indians and into the ALCS. This year, I'm very happy, but I can't believe what happened. The Red Sox did some good things to advance their cause, but they got a lot of help from the A's.
Before the playoffs started, Larry Mahnken told me that he was taping this year's playoff games and that I could get copies off him if I wanted them. Well, Larry, if you taped the Boston-Oakland games, I'd definitely like to get copies off you. I'm definitely going to need to see all of that again.
For now, however, I'm exceedingly happy that the Red Sox are in the ALCS. And I'm ecstatic that I have a ticket to game two of the ALCS, which will be the first playoff game I will have attended in person in my life.
I picked the Red Sox to beat the A's in five games and the Yankees to beat the Twins in four games in my ALDS previews, so this is what I expected to happen. However, I definitely knew that there was a good chance that the ticket I have for game two of the ALCS at Yankee Stadium would not have included the Red Sox. And I also knew there was some chance that the Yankees would not make the ALCS and I wouldn't have a ticket to game two.
So, I'm thrilled that everything worked out just the way I wanted it to, and I've got one explanation for why it did -- my authentic Nomar jersey.
My girfriend, Stacy, bought me my authentic Nomar jersey for Valentine's day and I kept it safe and clean in my closet for many months. Finally, on Friday, Sept. 3, I took it out and wore it for the first time. The reason being the Red Sox were playing the first game of a crucial three-game series against the New York Yankees.
The Red Sox won that game, and then I put the jersey away for awhile again. Sunday, I wore it while watching the Red Sox eke out a dramatic victory in game four of the ALDS. Monday, I wore it for the third time, and for the third time, the Red Sox won.
Coincidence? Probably. But there are some things I'm superstitious about, and you can bet I'll be wearing that jersey if the Red Sox are facing elimination against the Yankees.