Fantasy Friday
Evaluating the hitters
After almost four full weeks of baseball, hitters who are still slumping are starting to be more of a problem and hitters who are still on a tear are starting to look like the answer to all problems. However, it's still too early to make any rash decisions in fantasy baseball. To help you out, I've picked five different hitters to represent each of four categories - sell high, hold on, buy low and cut bait. (Note: I'm writing based on 5x5 Rotisserie leagues, but I would mention the same players in most leagues).
Sell High
These are hitters who are having monster years so far and aren't likely to finish with numbers anywhere near the ones they are currently putting up. You should try to trade them now and get as much value for them as possible. Here are my five in no particular order:
Tim Salmon - Salmon already has six home runs and is batting .325 while on pace to drive in 118 runs and score 125. Salmon is a career .285 hitter who hit 39 homers combined the last two years. He hasn't had more than 100 RBI since 1997 and he's only plyed more than 140 games once in the last five years. He's 34 years old and this is not a new level of production for him, he's simply hot and you should trade him while he is.
Shea Hillenbrand - Everyone thinks Hillenbrand is off to a great start because he's batting .321 with 22 RBI. Well, his OPS is only .816. Hillenbrand is traditionally a fast starter and last year he posted a .972 OPS in April before finishing the season with a .293 average, 18 homers and 83 RBI. He has only hit one homer this year and if he cools off from this start he will end up being terrible. I find it hard to believe that he's transformed into a .320 hitter, but he should still hit about .295 with 15 homers. See if you can find somebody who thinks he'll hit .315 with 120 RBI.
Geoff Jenkins - Jenkins is hitting .355 with four homers and 16 RBI. Jenkins is a good hitter (he hit .303 with 34 homers in 200) in the prime of his career (28 years old), but he just can't seem to stay healthy. He's never played more than 135 games, he played just 172 games the last two years combined and he's already missed a few games with injuries this year. I was watching baseball on ESPN the other night and Rob Dibble said that if Jenkins can just stay healthy, he'll drive in 130 runs. Logically, that statement is true because when the antecedent of an if-then clause is false (and Jenkins will not be able to stay healthy), the entire statement is true. Realistically, Dibble is one of the dumbest people around and you should trade Jenkins if you can get anything good for him.
Jorge Posada - Posada is easily the best hitting catcher in the AL and one of the top three in the majors. However, he's not this good. He's hitting .306 with seven homers and 21 RBI. He's a career .269 hitter with highs of 22 homers and 99 RBI. His hot start combined with the extreme weakness of the catching position makes him very valuable. If you can trade him for a first or second-round caliber player, you should, especially if you have a decent backup catcher.
Jose Cruz Jr. - Thanks to beginning the season in front of Barry Bonds in the lineup, Cruz is hitting .309 with six homers and 15 RBI. Through the first eight games of the year (batting ahead of Bonds), Cruz was hitting .371 with five homers. Since then (hitting behind Bonds), he's hitting .261 with just one homer. Since he does have some power and speed, he's been talked about as a 30-30 hitter this year. I don't think he'll reach those numbers and his batting average will end up closer to his career .253 mark than his current number. See if you can find somebody who thinks he's become a better hitter now that he's in the same lineup as Bonds.
Honorable (or obvious) mentions: Marcus Giles, Mark Grudzielanek, Sean Casey, Milton Bradley, Alex Gonzalez (FLA).
Hold On
These are hitters who are off to great starts, but should not necessarily be traded. They will probably cool off a bit, but what they give you in the long run is better than what you'll likely be able to get in a trade.
Austin Kearns - He's leading the majors with nine home runs, and it does not surprise me at all. He "only" hit 13 homers in his 107-game debut last year, but he can flat out mash. If he doesn't hit 40 homers with an average near .300, I'll be a bit surprised. If you're in a keeper league, you can look forward to some home run titles in the near future. Don't trade him this year and definitely keep him for next year if you can.
Preston Wilson - After two subpar seasons, the only question about his move to Coors Field was how much it would help. Well, he's hitting .333 with four homers, three steals, 15 runs and 15 RBI. He should get back to his 30-30 level (or better) with the best batting average of his career. He is a bit of an injury risk, so if you can get a great player for him you might want to. Otherwise, keep him in your lineup and just watch for any little injuries.
Raul Mondesi - After last year, Mondesi probably doesn't have much value at all, but he still has big-time power and speed. He's part of a lineup that's an offensive machine and there's no pressure on him. He obviously won't hit .345, but his six homers and four steals aren't out of line. Trade him for a great hitter if you can. Otherwise, hold onto him and enjoy the 30-30 season.
Edgar Renteria - Renteria's been around for so long that everybody forgets that he's just 27 years old and entering what should be his best offensive years. Last year was his best all-around season as he hit .305 with 11 homers, 77 runs, 83 RBI and 22 steals. This year, I expect him to hit .315 with 20-25 homers, 100-plus runs, 90-100 RBI and 20-30 steals. He should be the best shortstop in the NL and maybe the third-best overall.
Carl Everett - No player has more bad feelings associated with him than Everett, but he can really hit when he's healthy. He won't keep hitting .348 and he's not going to finish with 52 homers, but don't just trade him for whatever you can. With that ballpark and that lineup, Everett's perfectly capable of hitting .310-.320 with 35-40 homers.
Honorable (or obvious) mentions: Rafael Furcal, Jerry Hairston Jr., D'Angelo Jimenez, Raul Ibanez, Jason Kendall.
Buy Low
Johnny Damon - Damon is only hitting .250, but he's usually a slow starter. Also, he already has four homers and four steals, so the low average isn't hurting too much yet. When he does get his average (and his OBP) up, he'll start scoring runs by the dozen with the lineup that's behind him. He's already scored 18 runs with his low .323 OBP. If the Damon owner in your league is upset with the average, see how cheap you can get him. If you have him, just leave him in your lineup.
Paul Konerko - Konerko's hitting just .211 with two homers and eight RBI. He should not be in anybody's lineup right now. However, Konerko's posted an OPS between .844 and .863 each of the last four years. He'll eventually get back up in that range and his average, home run and RBI totals will be in line as well (.280-.300, 25-30, 90-105). If you can get Konerko for a song, just stash him on your bench until he shows signs of stirring.
Lance Berkman - Berkman's hitting just .236 with two homers and four RBI, but his strikeout and walk totals (10 of each) show that he's not pressing too much. He hit his second homer of the season yesterday and he combined for 76 homers and 254 RBI the past two years. He'll be fine and you should get him cheap if you can and hold on to him if you've got him.
Ichiro Suzuki - Ichiro's hitting .273, but that's not what you want from a career .332 hitter with little power, especially if you were hoping he'd return to his rookie-year level. If you can find somebody who thinks he's a .350 hitter who will steal 50 bases, you should trade him. If you hold on to him, he'll probably give you a nice .320-.330 average with 30-35 steals and 110-plus runs.
Toby Hall - For the second straight year, Hall is off to a slow start. He's hitting .246 with two homers and six RBI after hitting .206 with three homers and 21 RBI before the All-Star break last year. After the All-Star break last year, he had the same homer and RBI totals, but raised his average to .309 and in between his 165 at-bat sessions in the majors he tore up the International League with the Durham Bulls. You may want to put him on your bench for now, but I expect him to make an impact this year. If you're in a keeper league, try and get him because he could be the next great-hitting catcher.
Honorable (or obvious) mentions: Chipper Jones, Carlos Beltran, Jason Giambi, Miguel Tejada, Pat Burrell.
Cut Bait
These are hitters who are off to slow starters and probably won't be worthwhile fantasy contibutors this year. If you have them, you may as well cut them and look for somebody else.
Tony Womack - I've never been a fan of Womack because he doesn't hit for a good average and he has no power. He is fast though and he stole at least 45 bases for four straight years from 1997 to 2000 (with a high of 72 in 1999). The last two seasons, though, he's been unable to top 30 steals and this year he's hitting just .202 with two steals. Drop him and forget about him because he's 33 and not getting any better.
Adrian Beltre - Beltre has hit for a decent average and modest power the last four years and we've all been waiting for that breakout year because he's so young. Well, that year's not coming. He's hitting .177 and the Dodgers seem fed up. It's possible that Beltre will turn it around and eventually become a superstar, but it's also still possible that Ryan Leaf will eventually become a decent NFL quarterback. Let Beltre go just so you can stop wondering if he'll ever put it all together.
Fred McGriff - McGriff might get to 500 homers, but it won't be this year. He's 39 years old, playing with an awful lineup in a terrible hitters park. If he comes within shouting distance of last year's numbers (which weren't great for a first basemen), I'll be shocked.
A.J. Pierzynski - Pierzynski's fantasy value last year came entirely from his .300 average. This year he's hitting .254 and he still doesn't have any power. In deep league, he may be worth keeping around as a backup, but there's a reason the Twins took catcher Joe Mauer when they had the first pick - Pierzynski's just not that good. He's not in Minnesota's long-term plans and he shouldn't be in yours either.
Kenny Lofton - Lofton was able to put together 29 steals and 98 runs last year, but most of that (13 steals and 28 runs) came during his torrid April. He may steal 30 bases again, but he won't score anywhere near 100 runs and his batting average will kill your team.
Honorable mention: Mark Bellhorn, Randy Winn, Fernando Vina.
I know I said this would be up between 10 and 11 and now it's 11:45, and I'm sorry for the delay. There were problems with blogger.com and I had to retype some of this, so thanks for bearing with me. Next week, I'll look at pitchers using the same four categories.